Those frosting filled Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cakes are kind of it when it comes to holiday treats. Come on. You might be trying your hardest to stay on that “clean eating” diet of yours. But no one can resist the icing-laced goodness that the girl in the cute little hat brings. So when Little Debbie (the company, not the girl) tweeted a pic of some of their most-loved treats along with “One Gotta Go Forever…” people kind of freaked.

The tweet includes the beloved Christmas Cakes along with the iconic Nutty Buddy, the ambiguously healthy-ish Oatmeal Creme Pies (okay, so there’s really nothing healthy about these oatmeal sweets) and everyone’s favorite breakfast buddy, Honey Buns. Whoa.

Seriously. Can you imagine losing one of these sugar-packed, fat-laden treats forever. Sure, they’re not exactly nutritious by any stretch of the imagination. But they’re also part of American snacking history. And now Little Debbie wants to take one away from us?

As it turns out, Little Debbie is not discontinuing any of its snacks. Nope. Of course, that didn’t stop the treat makers from tweeting, “We didn’t say it would be easy. #OneGottaGo” the very next day. It doesn’t seem like anything actually has to go. But the tweets did certainly get everyone talking.

If you had to choose one Little Debbie snack to go, which one would you choose? Tell us in the comments below.