True fans know that pastry love extends way beyond grandma’s apple pie. From shepherd’s to Boston cream, there’s more to pie than meets the eye. Click through the slideshow below to see some unexpected sweet and savory takes on your favorite slice.

Puff Pastry Tomato Cheese Pie

Forget pizza delivery. Turn instead to frozen puff pastry, which takes center stage in this easy pie recipe from food blogger An Italian in My Kitchen. Get the recipe.

What’s your favorite pie recipe? Fill us in below!

— Erin Lem and Susie Foresman