On December 12 James Corden and wife Julia Carey welcomed their third child into the world. Born a few weeks before her due date, the couple’s baby girl made her grand debut before Corden and Carey had officially picked a name. Hey, we all know how much of a challenge it is to pick the baby’s name. It’s kind of a forever thing. And the wrong name can make your kiddo miserable for years to come. So when Corden joked about naming their daughter Beyoncé, his wife wasn’t exactly amused.

The Late Late Show host made the big announcement via Twitter positing, “Today we welcomed a beautiful baby daughter into the world. Both she and her mother are doing great. We can’t stop smiling.”

As the couple cried, tears of joy of course, the doctor asked what the baby’s name would be. In perfect comic fashion Corden answered, “We’re going to call her Beyoncé.” Umm, Beyoncé? Obviously, Corden was joking. But that joke may have been lost on the L&D nurse. When the nurse started filling out the birth form with “Beyoncé” as the name, Corden had to stop her.

While the couple won’t be naming their baby after the one and only Beyoncé, they are still yet to pick a name for her.

What’s your baby name vote for the happy new parents? Tell in the comments below.